The logo needs to be able to printed onto decals and screen printed on to products. Probably no more than 3 to 4 colors.
I have a suggestion that we start with a "cross hair" logo like you would see if you were looking through the scope of a gun. In the upper right quadrant of the cross hair you create a fish image, and in the lower left quadrant you create an image of a buck. (deer) This would be step 1.
Step 2, and more challenging would be to then put this image inside of a "crest" like an old school European type crest.
There may or may not be a tag line in the logo, but the words, "Trophy Strike" need to be part of the logo some how.
Again the colors will be Orange/Black and Grey. Some shading and fading is OK for printed decals and web art but for screen printing on thing like Ice Shanties, Tree Blinds, etc we will need a solid color version as well.
Attached images are for reference.....please be considerate of trademarks.